This episode is huge with its lore implications if I’m interpreting the scenes correctly. The episode opens with Subaru being denigrated by Petelgeuse and Regulus in the dark world that we’ve seen Satella/the Witch of Envy in before, such as when Subaru remembered having his heart squeezed and the isolation of that dark world when Puck used Shamak, in the White Whale fight when Subaru was pulled into the dark world so that Satella/the Witch of Envy could say that she loves him, and during the moment when Subaru intended to reveal Return by Death to get Petelgeuse to give up on possessing his body in which Petelgeuse was also pulled into the dark world but rejected by Satella. Given when Subaru tries to reveal Return by Death, the stench of Satella intensifies much like after he has looped back, this suggests that the dark world is a pocket dimension located within the vicinity of Subaru’s soul. This would make both Sirius and Emilia sensing Petelgeuse when Subaru uses Invisible Providence make sense, and it’s ’cause they sense Petelgeuse from within the dark world, and Sirius mistakenly believed that Subaru and Petelgeuse’s souls merged (I had mistakenly taken Sirius’s side last year in a blog post and failed to account for everything that came before that when I believe I’d been on the mark before that) when it was the case that Petelgeuse’s soul is just in close proximity to Subaru’s, which shows that Subaru’s body was constructed with a pocket dimension within the vicinity of his soul, which is not the case for any ordinary human, and that’s probably also the case for Al.
As for why this needs to be the case. I see no reason for a random Joe to have a pocket dimension within the container of their soul. This is Re:Zero, where there are logical reasons for events happening, not random isekai slop where there’s no rhyme or reason for the events happening, so it makes me doubtful that this sort of thing would happen for some random person in Re:Zero’s world. Need I point out that the whole point of Re:Zero was to summon Subaru, not an ordinary person? Authorities from the Witch Factors of the Seven Deadly Sins tend to make you batshit insane if what we’ve seen of the Sin Archbishops is representative of what happens, while Subaru still desperately clings to his humanity with all his being while having multiple of them. That doesn’t seem normal and actually extraordinary to me, to the point of being more than just human.
Now for something really juicy. For years, I’ve wondered why Subaru has recoil from using Invisible Providence offensively, which we’ve seen when he punched Garfiel in Season 2, when he hit Regulus in Season 3, when he crushed Regulus’s heart when it was attached to Emilia’s in Season 3, when Subaru punched Ram and sent her flying given he was sweating hard, breathing heavily, almost kind of slurring his words while advancing slowly to Ram to begin choking her, showing that he was pushing through the pain ’cause he had gone insane, and when he used his Authority against the faceless centaur mabeast to make it lose its footing. And now I believe I’ve arrived at an answer in that I believe that the regrets of the people in the dark world shape some aspect of Subaru’s Authorities.
Regulus’s regret is probably that his first wife laughed at him when she died when she had never showed emotion to him before that given he randomly went on without naming anyone about why you dared to laugh in your final moments in Episode 62, and that incident traumatized him, which is why he forced his future wives to agree to never smile or face death. Although Regulus is a an inhuman monster, he probably regretted that he never found out why his wife felt that way, so I believe Subaru’s Greed Authority will allow him to feel what others are feeling so that Subaru can understand and build better relationships with others. This is backed by Regulus stating in Episode 70 that Subaru violated his rights as an unselfish man who desires nothing but to settle for a tiny bit of simple, ordinary happiness, which shows that Regulus most likely just wanted a wife who loved him even though he killed everyone his first wife knew, which is why she never showed emotion and wouldn’t smile or laugh no matter what he did with him coping by telling himself he never needed any of his wives to laugh since it makes their faces uglier during the scene Reinhard had launched him into the sky.
If you’ve seen my Capella character analysis, I believe Capella’s regret is sleeping around so much and not getting to know the one she truly thought she could love, resulting in him treating her like a piece of meat like everybody else. To refresh yourself on that analysis, read this post: https://thoroughwatch.org/?p=44
Suffice to say, I think when Subaru defeats Capella, his Authority might be one that helps him and others around him get to know people they are attracted to rather than rushing toward intimacy. I don’t know what form that Authority will take, but I believe the effect I described will be close to what his Lust Authority will be used for after Capella is no longer of this earth.
I wonder what Sirius’s regret would be. My theory is that Sirius is the combination of Fortuna and a lesser spirit that matured during the Elior Forest attack that was in awe of Petelgeuse and Fortuna’s love for each other, and Sirius came into being when the spirit merged with Fortuna’s soul after Fortuna died, so if I’m right about Subaru’s Authorities being influenced by the regrets of those in the dark world, would it be Sirius’s regret that shapes Subaru’s Authority, or would it be Fortuna’s? I lean toward it being Sirius’s regret that would shape Subaru’s Wrath Authority since I believe Sirius is distinct from Fortuna. I remember in Season 3 during the fight against Priscilla, Sirius’s idea of love was everybody feeling the same thing, and that may have been born from when she was a lesser spirit who felt the intense emotions of Petelgeuse and Fortuna’s love for each other, and it may have misunderstood love as people feeling the same emotion for each other rather than grasping what love actually is.
I don’t know if Priscilla telling Sirius that real love is tolerantly accepting the differences of others would really be Sirius’s regret, but it could be possible if Sirius took it to heart given she seemed inspired by Liliana’s singing and started singing herself in a crude way, and she said that she’d try to drag Petelgeuse out of Subaru, so maybe she’s not all for making everyone feel the same emotion anymore if she wants Petelgeuse’s individuality to emerge from what she believes is Subaru’s and Petelgeuse’s souls amalgamating, so Sirius’s effect on Subaru’s Wrath Authority after Sirius gets killed one day may be an Authority that helps people shine by focusing on their own strengths instead of being worried about what areas they lack compared to others.
I surmise that if Subaru’s Authorities are indeed being shaped by those in the dark world, it’s to prevent Subaru from becoming a conceited person like previous Heroes of the story, forcing him to rely on others, even those he detested and defeated, which would be a great departure from the conceited and overpowered Heroes I believe came before him.
Back to the show, Subaru wakes up and wonders if he’s Returned by Death, which on the surface doesn’t really make the most sense given he wasn’t in the carriage before at his previous savepoint, and he passed out out after being saved by Shaula. But given the reason he believed this must be explainable, I’m thinking Subaru always spends some time in the dark world after dying before his soul loops back, and he just forgets everything about his time in the dark world although he subconsciously understands that he was there, and that’s why Subaru thought that he had Returned by Death, ’cause he subconsciously realized he was at the dark world deep down, meaning the Freud content from the previous episode may have come in handy. In the anime, Subaru hasn’t been to the dark world outside of after his body experiencing death since Season 1, so it’s been over a year since it’s last happened, making him thinking he Returned by Death the most plausible scenario to him given he’d just woken up and wasn’t thinking straight.
Subaru’s on Emilia’s lap, and that was intentional from Emilia given Beatrice said that Emilia gave up two nights of sleep for him, meaning Mr. Subaru was lying on Emilia’s lap a lot of the time, and he probably counts his lucky stars that that was the case. Subaru then exits the carriage and is told that they’re inside the Pleiades Watchtower. Shaula rushed to Subaru since he’s apparently her master, and she locks him in an extremely tight embrace that hurts him given how powerful she is, being distressed that her master doesn’t remember her, his student, and when Emilia wakes up and sees what’s happening, she gives Subaru a kick on the back rather than helping him out as he requested, showing her jealousy.
The whole group is surprised given Shaula barely said a word to any of them and is now clinging on to him for dear life and being very affectionate. Apparently, Shaula had been instructed by her master to never say more than she needs to no matter who asks her anything, and Subaru then tells her it’s okay to talk to the others given he knows Shaula believes him to be her master. Shaula then reveals when prompted that she’s not the Sage. Foxidna then throws Subaru three coins with her saying that the holy gold coin (the world’s word for platinum?) depicts the Divine Dragon, the gold coin depicts the first Sword Saint, and the silver one depicts the Sage, and of course the group remarks that it looks nothing like Subaru, prompting Shaula to say that she didn’t recognize Subaru by his looks but by his foul scent, showing that she can smell witch miasma. And Shaula knows the phrase, “No problem”, showing her master was someone who was originally from Earth. Shaula reveals that Reid was the first Sword Saint, calling him a stick swinger, and that Volcanica the sarcastic is the Divine Dragon. She hadn’t even realized just how much time had passed given Reid had passed long ago, showing Shaula isn’t an ordinary human given she doesn’t age and can smell Witch miasma. After Shaula insists that the group should know who the one she believes is her master, Ram said that her master hit her head on a chamber pot and forgot many things, leading to Shaula replying with “Again” to Subaru, showing that something is up here, revealing that her master is Flügel the Wise Man, the real Sage, the one who planted what was known as Flügel’s tree, the same tree the White Whale expedition force downed to trap the White Whale.
After that, it appears they group has been climbing the tower for a while, and Shaula is carrying Meili on her back with Meili complaining that it’s too bouncy of a ride, and Shaula says that a kid getting a free ride shouldn’t complain. Then Meili abruptly yanks Shaula’s ponytail, which is apparently a scorpion tail, not actual hair, and that fits the name Shaula given the name refers to a scorpion’s tail. When they arrive at the entrance, Beatrice says that Patrasche and Rem are a whole floor above this one, prompting Subaru to wonder aloud how they got Patrasche up that high, and Shaula revealed that she did it easily, which reinforces her incredible strength. I’m thinking the shot of Shaula carrying Patrasche may be an allusion. The most famous Patrasche is a dog from A Dog of Flanders, a TV series depicting a story of a boy and his dog in a village called Flanders within Belgium. Subaru’s ringtone in the White Whale fight was from A Dog of Flanders, clearing showing that he named Patrasche after the dog. The root of the name Patrasche is from Petr, derived from the Greek word, Petros, which means “stone”, with the author of A Dog of Flanders likely adapting the name to invoke a sense of enduring strength, which may be why Tappei wrote Patrasche in one scene of Re:Zero Season 2 to fling Subaru with such force that he was launched back into a building after he had deliberately escaped the building to flee from a very powerful mabeast, showing that Patrasche was thinking mainly of Subaru in that moment and did what she could to protect him even at the cost of her own life. I may be wrong, but I believe the shot of Shaula carrying Patrasche (stone) is a subtle allusion to Atlas carrying a celestial sphere with Atlas carrying a terrestrial globe (stone) being a misconception from a certain period of time about Atlas carrying the world since what Atlas was really doing in Greek mythology was carrying the celestial sphere which consists of the night sky. What may back up this interpretation is that in Belgium there’s the Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium that houses a famous 17th-century oil painting titled Atlas Holding up the Celestial Globe. Tappei could’ve chosen any name that meant “stone” or “rock” or had its root having either meaning, but he specifically chose Patrasche, possibly knowing of the association with Belgium and of that oil painting of Atlas, showing that Tappei does his research.
Subaru also reveals when they’re higher up the tower that he had previously heard that Flügel was the Sage and didn’t think his name would come up again, so I’m wondering where he heard it from given no one else in the group knew Flügel was the Sage. My best guess is that he heard the name Flügel from Liliana. As Liliana’s family was a travelling group of bards, the story of Flügel may have been passed down through the generations in her family. Even someone as long-lived as Beatrice didn’t know that Flügel was the Sage, so what was known about Flügel must’ve been lost due to time, possibly even ’cause of Echidna deliberately plotting to obscure knowledge of Flügel, much like how I am adamant she has been ensuring knowledge of past Witches of Sin has been lost so that the world blames everything on Satella, which is why Crusch and many others believed that mabeasts were created by Satella despite them actually having been created by Daphne, the Witch of Gluttony. As it started to hit Subaru about what it means to be climbing this tower, Shaula gives him 99 points out of 100, mostly ’cause of her affection for him, not ’cause of Subaru really realizing the gravity of what he’s doing since she says, revealing that the Pleiades Watchtower is a temporary name for a temporary role. To her Flügel being back means that it’ll return to its original role, which is that of the Pleiades Great Library where you can find everything you’ve ever wanted to know.
When the group reaches the floor where Patrasche and Rem are, Ram takes him into the dwelling of a spirit that has no will of its own that just heals the injuries and cures the sickness of those in it, and of course, Rem isn’t affected since she’s merely in suspended animation, and Subaru entrusts Ram with keeping Patrasche, who had been gravely injured, and Rem safe. He resolved himself to do what he needs to do and confirms sincerely that Ram looking over the two is more than enough, trusting that his not-really sister will do what she can.
Shaula then shares that this is floor basically functions as her den and is where she’s shooting intruders, referring to it as Hell’s snipe, another learned Earth phrase with the accompanying gun gestures along with it. Subaru finds out that Shaula was shooting people who approached the tower on her master’s orders all by her lonesome for four hundred years, so he ordered her to not harm him or his friends. And given Shaula is the Keeper of the Pleiades Watchtower, and the tower is named after a star cluster, and Subaru is the term for Pleiades, also known as the Seven Sisters, this may indicate that the decision to have Shaula be entrusted as its keeper was made by Subaru himself four hundred years ago, Shaula’s apparent master, who I’m not convinced is Flügel but moreso half of Flügel. Thus, much like how Zeus, the ruler of Olympus, forced Atlas to hold the heavens/night sky up, and how Flügel entrusted Shaula with the Pleiades Watchtower, it could be read as Shaula figuratively holding up the Seven Sisters in the night sky herself high up the tower similar to what Atlas did with the night sky in Greek mythology, a symbol of immense burden of responsibility, demonstrating the burden Shaula carried with her for four hundred years waiting for the return of her master, even to the point of forgetting that Reid was human. Maybe this is a pretty complex allusion, but I am adamant about its legitimacy nonetheless. Thus, this episode shows that Tappei had mapped out his story to this point with pinpoint accuracy having planned Patrasche to be used such in a way since at least Arc 3 of Season 1.
The third floor has a test that nobody in the group had been able to pass while Subaru had been sleeping. Touching the lone black monolith results in a very large amount of them emerging with the selection of the correct monolith being the test. A voice then emerges that states, “Hero slain by Shaula, touch upon his greatest splendor.” Touching the first monolith he touches ends the test, and touching it again reinitiates the test. The group in general has no idea what to do, and Meili then suggests that they ask Shaula, who doesn’t remember the names of people she killed outside of the first hundred, and she gives Subaru a thumbs up, also another thing not seen in this world. Subaru puts it out there that she killed Reid, which on the surface is strange given it was revealed earlier that Reid died of old age, but given the Sigmund Freud content last episode, maybe it’s not that strange, and Subaru used to know Reid. Given that Subaru almost certainly chose the path to the right in Episode 69 that led to Satella’s sealed body and that he thought he had Returned by Death due to subconsciously realizing he went to the dark world, Subaru may subconsciously realize that there’s a split-soul Reid in a vessel with everlasting youth that lies ahead on one of the higher floors since he knows what’s in this tower.
Of course, Subaru name-dropping Reid elicits pure terror in Shaula, resulting in her dropping Meili so that she could cower behind a monolith, and Meili referred to Subaru as “oni-san” as in “Big Brother” when he caught her, showing that Subaru has an easy time with making kids like him, meaning the Little Girl User is a fitting title for him. When Subaru asks if Shaula is that afraid of Reid, Shaula retreats to a monolith further away, and Julius follows that up by saying that Reid as the progenitor of Wilhelm and Reinhard must have been a man of great character, and he was crestfallen when Shaula mentioned that Reid was human scum who liked bullying those weaker than him, including herself. And Foxidna’s look of discomfort and gaze at Julius during that scene again shows again that she remembers Julius and was sad to see his reaction to learning that someone who may have been an idol to him was actually just a brat who never grew up given Foxidna had been with Anastasia for ten years and would’ve known who Julius probably admired from childhood..
It’s after Subaru heard about Reid’s strength that he gets some inspiration and realizes that the answer has to be something he’d know without asking Shaula since those who want to conquer the tower may have to defeat Shaula to enter it, so it has nothing to do with battle strength and somebody who Shaula has defeated in Re:Zero’s fantasy world, leading to him pondering of a different Shaula, and after he saw Shaula’s scorpion tail, that sealed the deal for him since Lambda Scorpii, formerly known as Shaula, is the second-brightest star in the constellation Scorpius and represents the stinger or raised tail of the scorpion.
Now for some more theorycrafting. Meili taking to Shaula so soon and basically clinging to Shaula seems surprising to me. Shaula also said that she has a scorpion tail, and maybe that was what she was using to snipe Subaru with in Episode 68. Given Ram saw a magic circle from Earth anime and manga, which shouldn’t exist in Re:Zero’s fantasy world, when she used her Clairvoyance, whatever Shaula was sniping with wasn’t a regular weapon powered by magic stones, which indicates she may be a being created by magic, specifically from someone who hailed from Earth.
Shaula having an affinity with Meili may also be why she didn’t create a huge scene out of Meili touching her tail and why Meili was clinging onto Shaula in the exam room when they no longer needed to climb further. Meili also never referred to Shaula by her action name, opting to call her “naked lady”, showing that Meili might see herself as Shaula’s superior, not requiring showing her the basic respect others get. A regular human even with eternal youth also wouldn’t be able to smell Subaru’s miasma. Thus, Shaula may either be a mabeast or a being similar in nature to a mabeast. And given her scorpion tail was key to Subaru gaining a hint he needed, this could be a part of the grand plan from four hundred years ago that I believe the heroes are enacting to bring about a free future. If Shaula is a mabeast, she had to have been created by Daphne, but if the scorpion tail hint for the test and Shaula’s outfit having Subaru’s tracksuit colours are pointing to anything, it’s also the case that she has a creator from Earth.
When Foxidna presses Subaru on how he figured out the answer, Subaru responds that it’s not a big deal and that it’s not their fault they couldn’t arrive at the solution since only someone from where he was from could know the answer since legends from his homeland talked about the hero, Orion, being killed by a scorpion, which resulted in Orion turning into stars, and that scorpion also becoming a star. When he had jumped up with Beatrice’s Murak before this, he had envisioned the constellations and saw both Rigel and Betelgeuse, the two stars of Orion that are said to shine the brightest, and Subaru chose Rigel since it shines consistently whereas Betelgeuse, which glows extra bright at times, and he took the test question with “touch upon his greatest splendor” as meaning he needed to choose the monolith representing the brightest star in Orion, and the Great Pleiades Library emerges. Subaru is of course dismayed by the enormous size of this library since as he said in Season 1, he’s the type to like to be rewarded for his efforts, indicating he doesn’t think working hard should be rewarded with even more work.
Now for my theory about how Subaru relates to Flügel. Of course it goes without saying that I believe that Re:Zero’s fantasy world is stuck in a cycle of being destroyed by the Witch of Envy and reconstructed as alluded to by Melakuera who talked about the Witch and the corresponding world imbalance and how he has faced world-ending crises countless times.
Subaru’s name is the Japanese term for Pleiades, which makes it fitting that the Seven Deadly Sins are used, and why since the brightest six of the stars are easily visible to the naked eye that there are six dead Witches of the Seven Deadly Sins in the story. The dullest star of the Seven Sisters is Asterope (Sterope I), which is part of the Sterope double star (Sterope I and Sterope II) in the Pleiades star cluster, and given the role Satella has in the story, it’s no surprise that Tappei made the Witch of Envy a separate personality from Satella, and had Satella sealed compared to dead like the others. And given Pandora and Hector exist, that’s 2 additional Witches of Sin outside of the main 7.
I am going somewhere with this beyond what I’ve usually posted. Michael Mästlin (anglicized as Maestlin) was documented to have mapped eleven stars in the Pleiades star cluster before the invention of the telescope in the 16th century. Michael Mästlin was German, much like how Flügel is a German name. Given Re:Zero’s fantasy world takes place in a medieval-ish setting, I theorize Tappei may have incorporated the number eleven in Re:Zero’s given, unless I’m mistaken, there shouldn’t be any telescopes in this world even though stars in the fantasy world aren’t like those from Earth, so Tappei may have decided to be Earth-accurate in making use of the number eleven. It is believed that 9 of these 11 were Alcyone (Eta Tauri), Atlas, (27 Tauri), Electra (17 Tauri), Maia (20 Tauri), Merope (23 Tauri), Taygeta (19 Tauri), Pleione (28 Tauri), Celaeno (16 Tauri), and Asterope (21 Tauri), which are known as the Seven Sisters and their parents.
I believe in the ancient past, an archetypal handsome, conceited, and overpowered hero typical of standard isekai slop in the moment in which he had to make the biggest decision of his life after the Seal in Elior Forest was opened, chose his lover, who had become the Witch of Envy, over the world, leading to the threat that came out of the Seal to be defeated, but the world was then destroyed following his choice to not strike down his lover, and when that hero made his choice, the final boss of the time activated his Authority to make the world extremely biased towards repeating the general path that archetypical hero followed on his journey. I don’t know the exact mechanism that the story can be biased toward following that path, but I nonetheless posit that it exists, and thousands or even millions of iterations of the story of the handsome, conceited and overpowered hero came and went as the world kept getting destroyed and reconstructed as the Hero of the story would have to fit that mold unless an intervention took place.
Thus, assuming the number eleven is important ’cause of Michael Mästlin, the Authority of the final boss in the ancient past was one that lets him/her control the story path to his/her liking, basically a super Authority if you will. I believe the ancient hero of the time also had a super Authority, although I won’t claim I know what it is assuming it’s real, and both the final boss and the protagonist having super Authorities would make the number eleven important.
Okay, after getting that out of the way, I still have more background content to cover, so bear with me. Episodes, 18, 25, and 38 show that Subaru has dormant memories of Satella as shown by how Puck indirectly revealed in Episode 18 the number of shadow hands Satella could generate to Subaru by asking Petelgeuse to summon 1,000 shadows if he truly wants to kill him, half of what Satella could (2,000), how Subaru used a number associated with Satella (2,000) to indicate his appreciation for Emilia in Episode 25 when he said that if Emilia named ten things she hated about herself he’d list 2,000 things he loves about her, which Emilia herself commenting on why he chose that number, and how Subaru suddenly had an upwelling of positive emotion for Satella in Episode 38 that led him to say that he’d save Satella after she asked him to love himself and then some day come kill her, which shows that Subaru and Satella may have a past history together as lovers given just moments ago, Subaru had been calling her an unfathomable monster he could never hope to understand, showing they must’ve had a very positive relationship in the past.
Al, Priscilla’s knight, in Season 3 also referred to Beatrice as Beako much like Subaru does, and I don’t believe that this means that Subaru and Al are the same person. However, I do believe that he and Subaru both originally came from the same soul. As I have said before, I have been researching the names of Re:Zero characters since Episode 22, A Flash Of Sloth, since that title could’ve referred to multiple things in that episode, and what may be relevant is that Subaru’s dad is named Kenichi, which means ‘wise man’. Subaru said in Episode 16 that Flügel’s Tree was planted by a wise man centuries ago, and while this wouldn’t mean something in a different show, its presence in a show with Re:Zero’s long-term planning suggests that Kenichi himself might be Flügel, and given Shaula referred to her master as Flugel the Wise Man, it’d be very fitting if Kenichi were him. Also of note is that Satella developed a separate personality in the Witch of Envy, who can barely talk, and the vocabulary we’ve seen from her so far is limited to “Love you” and “Love me”, and Subaru directly referred to her as the Witch of Envy in that Season 2 episode whereas when we saw Satella in Episode 38, the dead Witches of Sin were calling her Satella, which makes sense given Satella can speak in full sentences. Thus, Satella’s lover four hundred years ago may have also developed a split personality, who was Subaru, and that’s how Subaru can have a different appearance four hundred years ago given Shaula said that she recognized the current Subaru as her master by his scent, not anything else given she recognized the one depicted on the coin as her master, who didn’t look anything like Subaru.
Flügel itself means wing and can also be a nickname for someone with conspicuous sleeves at a time of dress regulations, so what this points to is that Flügel is a person not from Re:zero’s fantasy world who somehow came to be there given the nickname is for someone who dresses strangely, and this suggests that Flügel is from Earth. Perhaps Kenichi literally is Flügel, and it would make sense for Flügel to be Kenichi since I stress that Shaula didn’t recognize Subaru by his looks, which shows Subaru canonically had a different body four hundred years ago.
Satella most likely summoned the current Subaru to Re:zero’s fantasy world, but how did Kenichi get there if he is Flügel? Well, wings are symbolic of power, speed, and limitless freedom of motion, and maybe that’ss how Kenichi, if he is indeed Flügel, managed to make his way back to Earth after being in Re:zero’s fantasy world. Perhaps Kenichi has the power to freely travel between the two worlds because he has a limitless freedom of motion, and that would be how he ended up in Re:zero’s fantasy world in the first place. Given Kenichi is so badass and handsome and ripped as hell, he could’ve fit the mold of the handsome, conceited, and overpowered Hero of the story with the power to freely travel between worlds being his super Authority, and he likely gave himself the name Flügel when he arrived in Re:zero’s fantasy world to help himself fit into that world.
As for how Kenichi could split his soul, he likely couldn’t when he was the the Hero of the story of the fantasy world as his soul may have been indivisible since the story required for the Hero to make it to the end and repeat the cycle since dying ’cause his soul was eradicated wouldn’t be permitted as one of the parameters of the story path requires him to make it to the end to bring about the next cycle, meaning he couldn’t split Subaru from himself then, but after returning to Earth and losing his Hero designation, he should freely be able to do that using whatever tool Echidna used to cut her soul off as part of her immortality experiment since he wouldn’t have that privilege he had as he lost his Hero designation. Satella and this group of characters basically hijacked the path of the story in an attempt to save the world. The reason Kenichi couldn’t kill Satella himself was that he would always have a second personality that arose who couldn’t bear to kill Satella since his entire world was Satella, which is why he had to defer the task to someone else. Thus, Subaru being the protagonist of Re:Zero is to make up for him being why Satella couldn’t be killed in the past, making it a true redemption story unlike so many other stories billed as redemption stories when the characters don’t even have to address their character flaws, and thus, Subaru may be one half of Flügel, making Naoko telling Subaru to be half as cool as his dad in the first Sanctuary Trial potential foreshadowing of the situation four hundred years ago. Thus Flügel, the being I believe to be Kenichi and Subaru from four hundred years ago, may have been Shaula’s other creator who came from Earth.
Also of note regarding Michael Mästlin is that he was the first person to publish an account of Earthshine, the illumination of the moon by sunlight reflected from Earth. Given one of the kanji for Natsuki in Natsuki Subaru and Kenichi means “moon”, it could mean that Subaru and Kenichi are both associated with the Moon and that the Earth will always reflect on their fates and stories. Another name for Earthshine is The Da Vinci Glow, and there conveniently is the Da Vinci Crater on the Moon. And historically, Earthshine was referred to as “The old Moon in the new Moon’s arms”, and it may be an Easter egg on why Tappei has possibly set up Subaru inheriting the torch of saving the world from Kenichi.
Given we know Echidna succeeded in creating a soul clone of herself with how Echidna spoke in her own voice in Ryuzu Shima’s body in Episode 49 and how Foxidna herself is almost certainly a soul cone of Echidna’s given Re:Zero Break Time Season 4 Episode 3 had Foxidna calling Beatrice a kindred soul, which could indicate that they’re not just similar in nature but also similar in origin, then it wouldn’t be a surprise if Kenichi, if he is Flügel as I speculate, also did that as well, and Subaru and Al were both split off from Kenichi’s soul, and Kenichi made his sons his soul clones with that explaining why Al and Subaru both call Beatrice ‘Beako’, not ’cause they are the same person but because they were originally from the same soul. It’d also explain why Subaru has dormant memories of Satella despite it not being possible for him to have lived at that time under normal circumstances and why Al also likes being rewarded for his efforts much like Subaru does, all of which shows that Al isn’t Subaru but that his origins are likely similar, and that something is up with Subaru and Al that doesn’t involve time travel or straight up reincarnation, so Al and Subaru may be homunculi or artificial humans who were split off from Kenichi’s soul.
I believe Subaru, and previously Al, is being put through the wringer to fulfill the grand plan I believe the heroes from four hundred years ago implemented, which included Satella, Echidna, and probably Flügel, to save the world from being stuck in a cycle of being destroyed by the Witch of Envy and reconstructed as hinted by Melakuera in the Frozen Bond OVA due to the actions of an archetypal handsome, conceited, and overpowered Hero, and Satella destroying half the world four hundred years ago perhaps being a deliberate intervention that was needed to allow the heroes of that era to deviate from the archetypal story path to pave way for first Al and then Subaru with Al’s creation being a trial run in making the perfect Hero with Al’s failure being a necessary lesson for Subaru in the future and also ’cause Al’s future knowledge will be important in the future. I believe both Subaru and Al may be missing the super Authority that previous Heroes of the story had, in part to keep them honest unlike those that came before them although I don’t rule out that the super Authority is suppressed or sealed rather than being completely missing, meaning it could emerge later.
Why I say Al’s creation may have been a trial-run Hero is that he appeared to be the type of person Roswaal wanted Subaru to be. In Season 3, Al wanted Emilia to be dependent on Subaru and stay out of trouble instead of being her own person with her own contributions, which is exactly how Roswaal intended for things to go with Subaru with Subaru completing all three of the Sanctuary Trials and making Emilia dependent on him for the rest of his life. Al not having his gate shattered, which is why he can use the magic he does, may show that he likely didn’t save Beatrice when he was the Hero of the story and never entered into a contract with her. However, he may have acquired Beatrice’s not-quite-Tome of Wisdom when he was the Hero, and that’s how he was able to conveniently time the opening of the Watergate in Season 3 when he did, conveniently kill the rest of Priestella’s Council of Ten, and conveniently wake up Beatrice when he did, and that’d be ’cause he was acting upon advice from Echidna.
I don’t believe that Roswaal’s not-quite-Tome of Wisdom truly did the tell the future as if it did, the omission of Otto simply wouldn’t happen. What that shows is that the source of the knowledge didn’t intend for Roswaal to be victorious over Subaru. For those of you who think Echidna was serious about Subaru accepting her contract, consider the following content from Season 2 from my blog post I posted this year: https://thoroughwatch.org/?p=223
Also of note is that in Re:Zero Break Time Season 4 Episode 4, Subaru was hugging Ram tight when they were both asleep. He must’ve been very worried for her given in Episode 69 they were both in poor shape and saved by a mystery person who they didn’t know was friend or foe, so it just shows how much Subaru cares for Ram. Ram being so embarrassed about that was hilarious. And here’s the link to it: Re:Zero, Break Time 70 – English Translated
